Ben Affleck is… Batman?!

Ben Affleck is… Batman…apparently.

Image

It’s been announced that Ben Affleck will be replacing Christian Bale as Batman in the next Superman sequel (http://variety.com/2013/film/news/ben-affleck-is-the-new-batman-1200586881/). In all honesty, I’m not sure how I’m supposed to react to this!

Like a lot of Batman fans, I was really apprehensive after the San Diego Comic Con announcement that the next installment in Zack Snyder’s Superman franchise would feature Batman. Batman Vs. Superman actually. It actually makes me cringe. Is this necessary? Can someone at Warner Brothers or DC Comics stop this?!

Image

Christopher Nolan’s sophisticated and (in my opinion) nearly perfect Batman trilogy (Batman Begins, The Dark Knight and The Dark Knight Rises) is a mature, somber and very serious take on a character that has been misrepresented for too long. Us Batman fans have suffered through Val Kilmer’s mumbles, Jim Carrey’s leotard, George Clooney’s nipples, Joel Schumacher’s happy-meal inspired visuals and Arnold Schwarzenegger’s “Ice to see you” lines…wait…I take that back…I use those jokes all the time.

Batman, as we know him today, is a dark and complex character. He’s an orphan, a genius, a detective, a billionaire, but above all, he’s human. That’s the fact that makes him such an interesting and compelling character. Christian Bale did an amazing job with the duality of the Bruce Wayne/Batman character, and with The Dark Knight, Christopher Nolan provided us with the best superhero film to date.

When The Dark Knight Rises was released, both Christian Bale and Christopher Nolan declared that their trilogy was a full story, one that had run its course. Bale had decided that he wouldn’t be wearing the cape and cowl again, and Nolan confirmed that he wouldn’t be directing any more Batman films. I actually let out a sigh of relief – finally, FINALLY, my favourite superhero had a great trilogy, with a great actor and director at the helm. A series of films that were taken seriously and respected by critics and audiences alike.

And now this Batman Vs. Superman nonsense emerges…. I honestly didn’t think that they’d go through with it.

Let’s think back to The Dark Knight and the initial internet-rage focused on casting Heath Ledger as the Joker. Some people reacted like it was the end of the Batman-world. I’m just going to put this out there – as a fan of Heath Ledger, I fully supported that casting decision. I hate to say I told you so (but I will) – that turned out to be the best Batman-film casting decision, and the only Oscar-winning comic book character portrayal. I’m not necessarily against the casting of Ben Affleck. I really do like dem apples, as an actor and a director. But, Affleck as Batman?! I’m not sure that this even works. But if it does, I fully expect Matt Damon to be Robin. (Fun Fact: Bale absolutely refused to be involved if Robin was introduced as Batman’s sidekick).  Initial reactions have been mixed, to put it lightly – I think people are remembering Daredevil.

In this case, I think I’m more opposed to the film than the casting!

Is this new Batman/Superman hybrid film even feasible?

Image

DC’s rival, Marvel Studios has done a phenomenal job of weaving together story lines and character universes with the overall goal of The Avengers, which was in fact an absolutely great superhero and action film. They’d been leading up to that film for years, with after credit scenes and hidden easter eggs in films. It was a calculated and brilliant play on their part. DC and their respective film studios however, haven’t made any major moves in that direction. Talks and ideas about a potential Justice League movie have started up and fallen apart for years. There’s no cohesion between character universes, and the latest decision to “reboot” a character as central to the DC cannon as Batman, so soon after the conclusion of The Dark Knight Rises could make for some incredibly difficult comparisons. Will they have to re-introduce the character? An origin story? Pick up where The Dark Knight Rises left off? Has anyone thought this through? [Dark Knight Rises Spoiler Alert: Wouldn’t it have made more sense to cast Joseph Gordon-Levitt?]

Man of Steel was a disappointment (http://wp.me/p3pq8p-3d), but had the promise of possibly having a good sequel. Upon announcement of the imminent film (slated July 17, 2015 release date), Man of Steel actor Harry Lennix introduced the film with an excerpt from Frank Miller’s 1986 graphic novel series “The Dark Knight Returns

The excerpt features Bruce Wayne speaking: “I want you to remember, Clark. In all the years to come. In all your most private moments. I want you to remember my hand at your throat. I want you to remember the one man who beat you.”

Can you, in all honesty, picture Ben Affleck saying that to Henry Cavill?! The graphic novel is amazing, and we know that Zack Snyder is really good at recreating Frank Miller’s work (from his visually interesting, but ultimately unfortunate adaptation of 300). What works in comics might not work on film (The Watchmen, Green Lantern).  Batman vs. Superman, or Superman vs. Batman, or whatever they end up calling it is facing an uphill battle.

This could go one of two ways for Affleck: Argo-F***ing-Great! Or Argo-F***-Up-A-Franchise.

Image

Advertisements

5 thoughts on “Ben Affleck is… Batman?!

  1. Hmm.. this post might have confused my opinion even more. Don’t get me wrong, plenty of solid points were addressed, but I have a hard time believing that an educated fan base would put this on the same level/table/playing field as the Nolan trilogy. I mean, both characters have faced multiple interpretations in the past, but no one compares Man of Steel to Smallville, or Louis & Clark for that matter. I think with super heroes we’ve all accepted to take it as it comes, celebrate the victories and forget the losses (I reference the release of two Hulk movies within a 3 year span). I don’t know that a poor release will take anything away from the epic Bale trilogy for me.

    Now regarding my confusion, I just don’t like when known actors take roles otherwise associated with some childhood character. It’s just complicated to mix two distinct ideas, even if both are generally positive. The anxiety I feel hoping for a success, is not worth the possibility that it’ll work out. It’s like riding a train without buying a ticket; the chance of getting a free ride is not worth the paranoia I’ll feel for 20-30minutes. That being said, I guess the only antidote for my confusion is a summer release sometime in 2014.

    Alright, my time is up. I gotta see about a girl.

    So glad to see you’ve got a blog on the go.

    1. What an eloquent response!

      Completely agree with all of the above! I don’t know how to react to this news. I’m not sure if this sequel is supposed to fit into the Nolan-universe, or if it stands alone. For me, the Dark Knight trilogy is a completely different animal.

      Either way, I’ll still see it…and I think that’s the point. They’re looking to compete with ensemble superhero films like Avengers 2 and Guardians of the Galaxy… Big names attract audiences.

      Go see about that girl… and thanks for the feedback Din!

  2. It must be just me then. I’m actually looking forward to seeing Ben play Batman…though I agree, a clash between Batman and Superman would definitely not be my thing… Particularly since I believe the odds are stacked against Batman. And I like him better.

    1. I think, now that the initial shock is over, I’ve resigned to the idea that this movie is actually happening.

      I really like Ben Affleck – and apparently he might have signed up for this to get an opportunity to direct the JLA film (or other Warner Brothers projects). I don’t see Ben as Batman, it’s not Ben I’m worried about – it’s the movie!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s